The Interview Process Is Broken: What Companies Get Wrong and How to Fix It

The Interview Process Is Broken: What Companies Get Wrong and How to Fix It

Many articles have been written about lengthy interview processes, delayed decisions, and candidate frustration. None of this is new. As recruiters, we cannot recall a time when a drawn-out hiring process worked to a company’s advantage.

That does not mean companies should not be selective. You should be thoughtful. You should be thorough. You should hire the right person.

The issue is rarely about being selective. It is almost always about lack of organization or an attempt to accommodate too many internal opinions.

Good intentions. Poor execution.

What Actually Slows Down the Process

1. Trying to Accommodate Everyone’s Schedule

Scheduling is one of the biggest drivers of delays, especially during the summer or around holidays.

Start with the most senior decision maker and build the process around that person’s availability. If the CEO needs to be involved, their schedule should anchor the timeline.

If someone critical is unavailable, appoint a delegate. That delegation should be clear and intentional. If a CEO cannot participate, they should identify who interviews in their place and stand behind that decision.

2. Too Many Interviewers

Not everyone needs to meet the candidate!

We once had a client who wanted candidates to meet all their market leaders across the country. That required multiple trips and several days off work for each candidate, as well as weeks of coordination. It was not realistic.

Instead, we recommended a representative group. Two key leaders participated in the in-person interview day, and two others joined via a virtual panel interview. The result was a more efficient process without sacrificing insight.

3. Assessments That Create Friction

Assessments can be valuable. Poorly executed assessments are not.

We worked with a candidate who set aside three hours on a Saturday to complete a required exercise. He followed all instructions, reserved a quiet space at his local library, and logged in at the designated time. The issue was that the administrator responsible for granting access and overseeing the assessment was not available.

The candidate contacted us immediately. We worked with the hiring manager to locate the administrator. When she eventually responded, too much time had passed, and the candidate could not complete the exercise within the required window.

To his credit, the candidate was gracious and agreed to try again the following weekend after assurances that everything had been resolved. Unfortunately, the same issue occurred a second time. At that point, after committing two Saturdays and losing valuable personal time, the candidate chose to withdraw from the process. This was not a reflection of the candidate’s interest or commitment. It was a breakdown in execution.

If assessments are part of the process, they need to be well managed, properly administered, and respectful of a candidate’s time.

4. No Clear Point Person

One of the most common frustrations candidates share is inconsistent communication. Messages come from HR, the hiring manager, and sometimes an executive assistant. Details change. Timing shifts. No one owns the process.

There should be one point of contact. One person is responsible for communication, scheduling, and feedback. Without that, confusion is inevitable.

5. Interviewers Who Are Not Prepared

Too often, employees are asked to interview without guidance. They do not understand the role. They do not know what they are responsible for assessing. In some cases, they ask the candidate for what position they are interviewing? This is avoidable.

Each interviewer should understand:

  • The role
  • How the role fits within the broader organization
  • What they are responsible for evaluating
  • The type of employee who aligns with the company’s culture

A simple internal briefing or “Interview 101” session, built around your company’s mission, vision, and culture, can make a significant difference. It does not need to be complicated, but it should be intentional.

Applicant Tracking Systems often have features such as interviewing templates for hiring teams. AI may also be a helpful as it can quickly assist in building a tailored Interview 101 guide, including suggested questions, evaluation criteria, and role specific scenarios. These tools allow companies to create a consistent and repeatable approach without requiring a significant investment of time or internal resources.

In addition, interviewers should be prepared in advance. That means having:

  • The candidate’s resume
  • A copy of the job description
  • Any relevant background or context needed to assess the candidate effectively

These materials should be shared well before the interview is scheduled, not minutes before the conversation begins.

Preparation on the company’s side signals professionalism. It also leads to better conversations and more informed hiring decisions.

Why a Structured Process Matters

A defined process benefits both the hiring team and the candidate. It sets expectations:

  • How many rounds will there be
  • Who will the candidates meet
  • What format each step will take
  • How long will the process last

It also allows for flexibility when something unexpected happens.

Schedules change. Emergencies happen. A CEO required immediate surgery during a search. A candidate was involved in a car accident on I-95 on the way to an interview. Thankfully both the CEO and candidate were fine. The point is when the process is organized, it can adapt.

The Reality: Candidates Have Options

Many of the candidates we work with are not actively looking. Once they begin exploring an opportunity, that changes. They become more aware of the market. They take more calls from recruiters. They consider more options.

If another company offers a similar role with a more efficient process, you will lose that candidate. Not because your opportunity was not compelling. Because your process was not.

What We Do Differently

At CA Search Advisors, we establish the interview process at the outset. A typical structure might include:

  • Initial video call with HR
  • Follow up discussion with the hiring manager
  • A structured in-person day with key team members
  • A final executive conversation if needed

We define the timeline. We identify decision makers. We confirm availability. After each step, we gather feedback immediately and communicate next steps without delay.

We also discuss with candidates what other opportunities they are considering and the timing around those processes. That transparency allows both sides to move with urgency when it matters.

Final Thought

A streamlined hiring process is not about rushing decisions. It is about respecting time, maintaining momentum, and making it possible to secure the right candidate before someone else does.

Every company believes they have a strong opportunity. The ones that win are usually the ones that execute better.

 

Amy Bauer
Managing Principal and Co-Founder

amy@casearchadvisors.com
(443) 784-2555

 

Katie Becker
Managing Principal and Co-Founder

katie@casearchadvisors.com
(312) 802-0300